I need a Coven - Help Please!

[Turgle]

Alright so I was wondering what is needed to be done for Coven Witches to join your Coven.

I've made a Seer's Stone, I have a cat familiar, I've done the Infusion of Light, I've killed a Demon and I've defeated the Horned Huntsman. Is there nothing I can do to prove I am skilled in the art?

[Loader]

The cat familiar should be all you need to do (or any familiar).  You should try dismissing it and recalling it and see if that makes a difference.

[Turgle]

Thanks for the help, I now need to forsee the future to get my first Coven Witch

[Loader]

You need to take her something... something that helps you see the future.

[Turgle]

I gave her my Crystal Ball and then proceeded to spend 60 bones on another 2 Coven Witches

[Loader]

Always be prepared as you hand them the last stuff - sometimes you may be in for a surprise...

[Turgle]

Haha touche, I've heard of that before

 

Off topic, I went to the Moon, and the text didn't come up telling me I needed to slow down so now I've lost my best sword, my best pick, my Resonant Strongbox full of supplies for the Moon and apparently Enhanced Portals don't accept modifiers up there. Needless to say I feel kinda cheated out, and I can't easily replace my lost tools either.

And I spent so long preparing for it